American Pie (1999)


Dave’s 3-Word Review:
Immature, memorable characters.

This film was selected from ‘The 250’

So, craziest thing happened. I got a job. Something I haven’t had in years, and today is my first day. The reason I mention it is because in sharp contrast to my mature, responsible decision – I have decided to watch the first irresponsible and immature movie that came to mind, American Pie. Keep in mind that I haven’t actually seen any of the movies in this series, including the numerous spin-off films. I may have seen a clip here or there on TV, but that’s about it. I’ve decided to watch the main series with the main cast only, which starts right here.

We have a pretty typical teenage-genre film here, as we are introduced to a number of friends still in High School. Their plan is pretty simple, to lose their virginity before the end of school, specifically speaking – prom night. Of course, their awkwardness and young people issues often get in the way, and as it is also a romance film – the message of love and “it isn’t always about sex” is clearly obstacles, but are they welcome obstacles is the question.

Growing up in a highly conservative home, it is these types of films I typically avoid reviewing. One, because they aren’t really my thing. Two, they’re all pretty much the same thing. And three, it’s awkward. For such a movie with a simple, perverted plot…it can seem really childish in nature. Like one of those movies you either see or you don’t and a review isn’t really necessary. On the other hand, this series alone is incredibly popular as far as comedies go, landing four movies with the same cast. I had to find out why. I think I may have a good grasp on it. The characters are so good.

Forget about the plot for a second. The characters of Jim, Oz, Michelle, Vicky, Finch, Stifler, and Heather are all so, so well-written as well as acted. So much that I welcome the context of the plot of sexual depravity. There’s no better source for awkward and embarrassing experiences than that of a bunch of high school kids acting like complete idiots in the name of sex. Admit it. We were all idiots in high school for different reasons, and this is a pretty popular one. I can’t say we don’t have any films on this subject, because they’re all over the place, but I’m not sure we really have one that is this good that it’s actually believable. That’s what gets me. It’s equal in being over-the-top and believable at the same exact time.

However, I do have to say that for a modern audience, there’s really not that much about this film that’s utterly unique. You can love these characters all you want, which is well-deserved, but the plot of the film is simply something we’ve seen a thousand times over, and don’t really care to see more of. American Pie may have revolutionized this genre and created hundreds of copycats, but for someone that has never seen it, like me, a lot of what it was blended with the rest, and that is a big problem.  In short, it doesn’t stand out as much as it probably should. At least not anymore if it did when it first came out.

The comedy, I should mention, still works most of the time. That also has to do with the characters and how well they are written. It’s just that these scenes are so embarrassing that you almost want to look away…and that means it did its job perfectly, because while you’re looking away…you’re laughing. I won’t sit here and say all of the jokes click, but there are some decent laugh-out-loud moments that caught me off guard. So there’s that.

The Good:

The casting and characters of this film make it what it is. Their expressions lead to believable awkward and embarrassing situations that still make this film exceptionally comical.

The Bad:

Simply put, the plot blends in with hundreds of other copycats. Even if American Pie revolutionized the genre of teen comedy, the plot and concept alone has just been done way too many times.

8 thoughts on “American Pie (1999)

  1. Glad you kinda liked this as I think I may have recommended it to you a while back! There’s a lot of nostalgia tied up for me with this movie and it always makes me laugh. I agree with you that the characters are very strong and the cast make it all believable – which is a big ask! I can see your point though – in the wake of all the copycats American Pie might not offer modern audiences as much as it once did. It’s not American Pie’s fault and I’m sure it will be remembered as a game changer, it’s just a bit unfortunate. Now times are turning once again with the likes of Spring Breakers and The Bling Ring which will no doubt sprout their own copies 🙂


    1. Yeah, I think you did suggest it, haha. I’ve actually not seen Spring Breakers OR The Bling Ring, same reason I typically avoid these haha. idk perhaps one day


      1. Spring Breakers is weird. It’s not your usual teen movie so you might find something to enjoy in it. I admire it for breaking the mould but I’m still not sure if I actually like it.


  2. Just chiming in to say that Spring Breakers and American Pie are in two completely different universes. I loved it, but its strange enough to make it hard to recommend. I also love American Pie. You are correct, the characters are great. The movie is also highly quotable and has some iconic scenes. Both fuel its popularity.


Comment here, guys!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.